Over the last few years, storage manufacturers have introduced ATA RAID controllers as a budget-minded alternative to the entrenched SCSI RAID. Hard-drive makers turned out products with faster motors and larger buffers, hoping to close the performance gap with SCSI drives. Yet hurdles remained.
This was among the driving forces behind the development of the Serial ATA standard, which showed potential to address these issues. Now in its second revision, SATA is delivering what system builders have sought for years: good performance at an affordable price.
But the SCSI standard has not remained stagnant, either. Serial technology is everywhere. The newest SCSI standard—called Serial Attached SCSI, or SAS—is perhaps the ultimate convergence of ATA and SCSI technologies.
How does this benefit the server system builder? Let's find out by taking a look at SATA-II and SAS. Then, we'll build a RAID-capable server with SATA-II drives that can later be migrated to SAS drives while still preserving our hardware investment and without the need to rebuild the entire system from the inside out.
Summary of the Technologies
SATA-II offers some important improvements over the original SATA hardware standard. The SATA-II Working Group sought during development to ensure physical compatibility with upcoming SAS interfaces, and an agreement was worked out with the SCSI Trade Association to make this happen. This is an important reason why system builders now have the option of running SATA-II drives or SAS drives on the same backplane. SATA-II also carries forward the main improvements of SATA which are low cost, simplified cabling and connections, and backward compatibility for drivers and software.
SAS is the other side of the "convergence equation." The SAS standard and the protocols within it is what enables communications between SATA drives and SAS controllers. There are actually three different protocols available to SAS. These protocols are known as Serial SCSI Protocol (SSP), SCSI Management Protocol (SMP), and SATA Tunneled Protocol (STP). As you might imagine, SSP transfers SCSI commands across the data link to a drive, while SMP sends management information to an expander attached to the controller.
The real beauty, however, is STP. This is what enables SATA commands to be sent from an SAS controller to a SATA drive. Since the SAS connections are point-to-point instead of shared, we can have SATA-II drives and SAS drives installed within the same enclosure, and the controller can successfully negotiate the connection.
To the system builder who handles servers, RAID is not an option, it's a requirement. While increasing the number of drives in the system increases performance, it also introduces additional points of failure. This became a bigger problem with ATA RAID systems in the past, due to a longer error recovery process and lower Mean Time to Failure (MTTF) specs than SCSI drives. Also a problem for early ATA RAID systems was the lack of true hot-swap capability. Manufacturers are now addressing these issues with their versions of SATA and SATA-II drives designed specifically for use in RAID systems. This enables the system builder to create SATA RAID systems that are viable in production environments and are better able to compete with SCSI arrays. The convergence of SATA-II and SAS takes this conce
pt to the next level.
Ingredients
For our recipe, we will use components from Adaptec and Maxtor. Here's what you'll need:
Drive Enclosure: I recommend Adaptec's 335SAS, which fits four 3.5-inch SATA or SATA-II or SAS hard drives into the space of three consecutive 5.25-inch half-height chassis bays. This unit is available in either beige or black, with an MSRP of just under $370. Outstanding features of the 335SAS include: support for enclosure management, integrated cooling fan, redundant power connectors, and hot-swap capability. Here's a look at the Adaptec 335SAS drive enclosure:
Controller: Also from Adaptec is the 4800SAS RAID controller, which is an 8-port controller supporting SATA or SATA-II or SAS drives. This model, with an MSRP of $945, supports standard RAID levels 0, 1, 5, 10, and 50, plus Adaptec's advanced RAID levels 1E
, 5EE, and 60. The 4800SAS card has a PCI-X bus interface, which has excellent backward compatibility with existing PCI slots. A PCI-X card can be installed in a system with a 64-bit 66 MHz PCI slot or even a 32-bit PCI slot, in addition to the 64-bit 133 MHz or 100 MHz slots. The PCI bus interface is almost ubiquitous now; therefore, a PCI-X card such as this can be used to upgrade an existing platform with an open PCI slot on the motherboard. For new systems where this type of backward compatibility is not a concern, Adaptec's 4805SAS controller has a PCI-Express x8 interface and otherwise identical specifications. Here's a look at the Adaptec 4800SAS RAID controller:

Hard Drives: I recommend the Maxtor MaXLine Pro 500, which is a 500 GB, 7200-rpm SATA-II drive with a 16 MB buffer. This is an enterprise-class drive with improved Error Detection and Recovery features to improve reliability in RAID systems. The MSRP is around $300 each, giving this product an excellent price-to-performance ratio. Here's a look at the Maxtor MaXLine Pro 500:
This was among the driving forces behind the development of the Serial ATA standard, which showed potential to address these issues. Now in its second revision, SATA is delivering what system builders have sought for years: good performance at an affordable price.
But the SCSI standard has not remained stagnant, either. Serial technology is everywhere. The newest SCSI standard—called Serial Attached SCSI, or SAS—is perhaps the ultimate convergence of ATA and SCSI technologies.
How does this benefit the server system builder? Let's find out by taking a look at SATA-II and SAS. Then, we'll build a RAID-capable server with SATA-II drives that can later be migrated to SAS drives while still preserving our hardware investment and without the need to rebuild the entire system from the inside out.
Summary of the Technologies
SATA-II offers some important improvements over the original SATA hardware standard. The SATA-II Working Group sought during development to ensure physical compatibility with upcoming SAS interfaces, and an agreement was worked out with the SCSI Trade Association to make this happen. This is an important reason why system builders now have the option of running SATA-II drives or SAS drives on the same backplane. SATA-II also carries forward the main improvements of SATA which are low cost, simplified cabling and connections, and backward compatibility for drivers and software.
SAS is the other side of the "convergence equation." The SAS standard and the protocols within it is what enables communications between SATA drives and SAS controllers. There are actually three different protocols available to SAS. These protocols are known as Serial SCSI Protocol (SSP), SCSI Management Protocol (SMP), and SATA Tunneled Protocol (STP). As you might imagine, SSP transfers SCSI commands across the data link to a drive, while SMP sends management information to an expander attached to the controller.
The real beauty, however, is STP. This is what enables SATA commands to be sent from an SAS controller to a SATA drive. Since the SAS connections are point-to-point instead of shared, we can have SATA-II drives and SAS drives installed within the same enclosure, and the controller can successfully negotiate the connection.
To the system builder who handles servers, RAID is not an option, it's a requirement. While increasing the number of drives in the system increases performance, it also introduces additional points of failure. This became a bigger problem with ATA RAID systems in the past, due to a longer error recovery process and lower Mean Time to Failure (MTTF) specs than SCSI drives. Also a problem for early ATA RAID systems was the lack of true hot-swap capability. Manufacturers are now addressing these issues with their versions of SATA and SATA-II drives designed specifically for use in RAID systems. This enables the system builder to create SATA RAID systems that are viable in production environments and are better able to compete with SCSI arrays. The convergence of SATA-II and SAS takes this conce

Ingredients
For our recipe, we will use components from Adaptec and Maxtor. Here's what you'll need:
Drive Enclosure: I recommend Adaptec's 335SAS, which fits four 3.5-inch SATA or SATA-II or SAS hard drives into the space of three consecutive 5.25-inch half-height chassis bays. This unit is available in either beige or black, with an MSRP of just under $370. Outstanding features of the 335SAS include: support for enclosure management, integrated cooling fan, redundant power connectors, and hot-swap capability. Here's a look at the Adaptec 335SAS drive enclosure:
Controller: Also from Adaptec is the 4800SAS RAID controller, which is an 8-port controller supporting SATA or SATA-II or SAS drives. This model, with an MSRP of $945, supports standard RAID levels 0, 1, 5, 10, and 50, plus Adaptec's advanced RAID levels 1E


Hard Drives: I recommend the Maxtor MaXLine Pro 500, which is a 500 GB, 7200-rpm SATA-II drive with a 16 MB buffer. This is an enterprise-class drive with improved Error Detection and Recovery features to improve reliability in RAID systems. The MSRP is around $300 each, giving this product an excellent price-to-performance ratio. Here's a look at the Maxtor MaXLine Pro 500: